When running a giveaway, should I require email sign-ups or just accept social media comments?

Always require email addresses, not just comments. The value of a giveaway lies in collecting contact information you can use for ongoing marketing. A comment gives you nothing except a moment of engagement—you can’t reach that person again unless they happen to see your future posts. An email address lets you nurture that lead over time through newsletters, new release announcements, and relationship-building. If you only ask for comments, you’re giving away a valuable prize in exchange for almost nothing in return. Structure your giveaway with a landing page that collects emails, and clearly state that entering requires providing contact information. This is standard practice and makes your giveaway a true marketing investment rather than just a popularity contest.

---

Asked by an artist planning their first giveaway · Answered by Indra · art-marketing-101 · 2026-07-10