What kind of revenue can I realistically expect from my email list if I'm consistently building it and emailing regularly?

Here’s realistic math based on sending two emails per month with offers and having an average order value of $90 (typical for an art business with a full product range from $25-$5000). Generally, 1.5% of your list will buy each month at that average order value. If you capture 600 new emails per year through consistent effort: Year 1 (starting with 200, ending with 800 emails, average 500): approximately $8,100 in revenue. Year 2 (ending with 1,600 emails, average 1,200): approximately $19,400. Year 5 (ending with 6,500 emails): approximately $89,000. Year 10 (ending with 16,000 emails): approximately $226,000. These are conservative estimates. The key is working on capturing emails all year long through multiple methods - website, social media, in-person events, QR codes, direct mail - and emailing your list consistently. The compound effect is powerful when you have the fundamentals in place.

---

Asked by synthesized from teaching · Answered by Patrick Shanahan · art-marketing-podcast · 2026-05-29